Skip to main content

The Other Boleyn Girl: A look into the "Cranach" Gown

The other Boleyn Girl is a feature film directed by Justin Chadwick that premiered back in 2008. It's based on a novel by Philippa Gregory and it's a movie about the two Boleyn sisters: Mary and Anne, whom both became mistress of the infamous Henry VIII. It’s the story of a sibling rivalry that plays out during one of the key moments of the history of England; Henry’s break with the Catholic Church.


The Boleyns are an impoverished English noble family that wants to climb the social ladder of the Tudor Court. For that, they will push their daughters into the King’s bed. First Mary, and then Anne. But, whilst Mary is a sweet and tender girl who does only what her father asks of her, Anne, ambitious and cunning, goes the extra mile. She goes behind her sister’s back and starts courting the king. She then decides to refuse the King, who at this point is madly in love with her, unless he marries her. The problem, of course, lies in the fact that he's already married to Katherine of Aragon. Anne convinces him that if he marries her, she will give him the male heir he so desperately wants. Driven by his lust, Henry decides to divorce his wife, but the Pope refuses to approve it.  In his wrath, Henry decides to break off ties with Rome and name himself “head of the Church of England”. This allows him to divorce from Katherine, but also unleashes great conflict within the country. Nonetheless he marries Anne and crowns her Queen of England. Unfortunately, she gives birth to a girl, not the promised heir. Henry, accuses her of being a witch and adulterous and has her head chopped off.

It must be highlighted that this movie a highly fictionalized version of history. All these characters did exist, and the pivotal key facts did happen, but after all it is a Hollywood version of their stories (which means that a real complex and interesting story is played out as a mere tumultuous romance).

Despite all this, my main problem with this movie is not the “soap opera” feel of the story; is the unoriginality, lack of effort of the dress designer and the questionable choices he makes.

It’s not a terrible design (it’s not like “The Tudors” TV show), it’s just lazy. It feels like they opened the studios’ dress catalogue and picked those that fitted the time period, and didn’t put any effort in thinking what was best for each moment.

But, to add insult to injury, two of the dresses they picked are terribly misplaced; it’s the ones I call the “Cranach” Gowns. These appear early in the movie and only in a couple of scenes, but these actually manage to bugger the life out of me.

Both Portam and Johansson are dressed in "Cranach"'s gowns

The problem with these gowns is not that it’s out of period (which it isn’t) it’s that is out of place: this is a German - Saxon Renaissance dress, not English. 

This is a style of gown that has been introduced to the public by Lucas Cranach The Elder’s paintings. The 16th century German painter always depicted females with this same style of dress.

Three Saxon Princesses by Lucas Cranach The Elder

This type of gown has become very recognizable: its red velvet bodice trimmed with gold which is laced tightly across the stomach, revealing a smooth white underneath and its extremely full skirt that falls in tubular pleats with a wide brocade trim at the bottom, are its most distinct elements.

Here we can see a whole body
version of the dress

From Cranach’s work, one might be lead to believe that the women of the early 16th century Germany were all running around in these tubular pleats. But many people have questioned whether this style actually existed at all, or whether it was only a product of the painter’s fanciful imagination. Why would anyone think that? Because no actual gown has survived to this day. The closest  looking gown is one that belonged to Mary of Hapsburg, and dates back from the 1520’s.

This dress belonged to Mary of Hapsburg
and dates back from the 1520's

While this gown has a certain resemblance to a Cranach Gown, it’s still not similar enough to pose a defining proof of the existence of this type of dress. The gown differs, especially, in the type of sleeves and bodice. But, taking into  account that Cranach himself did do different versions of the dress, this may be, after all, a “Cranach” gown.

A slight variation in the style

The dress in black velvet is not
common in his paintings

Despite this, I do believe that the “Cranach” Gown did exist, even though it might have been nothing more than a short-lived trend highly concentrated in the Saxon Electorate.

But I'm going way off topic now. Let’s go back to today's issue: the gowns in “The other Boleyn Girl”. 

Both characters wear different spins on the Cranach Gown: Portman’s gown has a high neck, whilst Johansson’s gown has a neckless bodice (much more common in Cranach’s paintings). 

Portman's (Anne Boleyn) "Cranach"'s gown
This Cranach painting is wearing a dress
almost identical to Portman's
Scarlet's (Mary Boleyn) dress is also a variation
of Cranach's Gowns
Although Scarlet's dress is much more simple,
the bodices are pretty similar
The collar area of both dresses is almost identical

I must grant them that they do look really nice. These are not cheap dresses. And whomever designed them, did pay attention to detail. But all this effort is useless. Both dresses stick out like a sore thumb for one simple reason: this are not English Tudor gowns. This is a movie about Anne Boleyn, she should be dressed in English fashion. If they wanted to use the "Cranach" gown they should have done a movie about Anne of Cleves.

These are English gowns of the Tudor period:

This is a portrait of young Princess Elisabeth,
the future Elizabeth I

Another portrait of young Elisabeth

The differences are pretty easy to spot. The bodice is completely closed (no lacing) and the sleeves are always wide and plain. There are no tubular pleats skirts either, these are heavy skirts that fall down regally . And the head coiffure is clearly different. This kind of coiffure was very distinct by its shape; this coiffure was also common in France and Spain, but it was differently shaped.

Funny enough, the rest of the gowns in this movie do fit this description.


This one is actually very similar to the
second portrait of Elisabeth

Mary and Anne wearing the "typical" Tudor dress

Anne with her iconic green dress. Note how
different it is from the Cranach dress

All in all, I really don’t understand why they used these specific dresses for this movie, knowing that they were the only ones that actually steered away from the historical accuracy of the movie.

But right now, the question most of you will be asking is; is it really that important? 

It is. This is, after all, a historical piece. Why do it if you are going to ignore the period? This only makes sense when, as a director, you create a world detached from its historical reality. Joe Wright’s “Anna Karennina” is a fine example of this: it’s all shot within a theater as if the character are actors playing their roles (as to criticize the stiffness of the Imperial Russia). The moment you do that, “historical accuracy” flies down the window and you can have as much freedom as you want in your costume design (the movie, in this case, mixes 19th century Russian design with 1950s American design which creates a very unique and interesting world). But if you’re striving to do a regular historical piece, as this movie does, then you cannot take these licenses. Even if most people won’t notice.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

A look into Star Wars: Padme's Dresses. Annex A

As I'm sure I've mentioned before, the size of Padme's wardrobe is leaning towards big. One might even say gigantic. Because of this, we are forced to choose which ones we review and which ones we don't. Otherwise, we would still be reviewing the costumes from Episode I. Thanks to this selection process, right now, in our Padme series' we are reviewing costumes already from Revenge of the Sith. But lately, we've been thinking a lot about those designs that got "lost in the selection", as we call them.
WHY WEREN'T THESE SELECTED? Generally, those that we did not select for our series were considered "not interesting enough". But what does that mean? Well, it means two things; either they pulled from the exact same influences as any of the dresses we had already addressed (which would make for a very repetitive article) or were considered too simple and basic to talk about them at length.
And then, of course, were those that we simply did …

A look into Star Wars: Padme's Dresses. Part II

Let’s continue with our thorough examination of the designs of Padme Amidala’s dresses. This second post in the series will be dedicated to the also terribly famous “senate” gown from “The Phantom Menace”. She wears this dress during her plea at the senate in Coruscant, and it has grown to become a terribly well known gown.

This gown has several layers to it. The base layer is a bright orange silk dress, with a high collar decorated with ornate gold stitchwork and beads. Over this, she wears a dark red overdress with orange hems decorated with gold brocade. This overdress has big sleeves and its embroider with rosettes. Above this, she wears a dark and thick faux fur cloak with shoulder pads that make her look twice her size.

Although what really made this dress iconic, is the headdress that accompanied it. Amidala's hair was dressed in a wide arc centered by a golden headpiece with golden hairbands to keep her hair's shape. This arc was decorated with dangling orichalc suspens…

Creating the Seven Kingdoms. Part I: The North

As we promised a few weeks backs, we are going to cover more tv shows from now on, mainly because there is just too much awesomeness in our TV's these days to ignore it. And for the last 5 years, the crowning jewel of TV costume design has been, without a doubt, HBO's Game of Thrones. So it was only logical to start there.
The downside is that there is so much to talk about that it becomes really difficult to decide where to start exactly. G.R.R. Martin's sprawling epic covers many characters and many places, and therefore there's really a lot to pick up from. In the end, we decided that we would take a page out of the author's tactics and split it in several different series of articles to be published gradually. And so, this is going to be the first of many. And we probably should warn you, there will be spoilers ahead. CREATING THE SEVEN KINGDOMSGame of Thrones, from an adaptation standpoint, faced many of the same problems that Peter Jackson had to face when b…

A look into Star Wars: Padme's Dresses. Part I

I’ve decided to start this blog by dedicating the first posts to the designs of Padme Amidala’s dresses in the first three episodes of Star Wars. Although  I’m not particularly fond of these movies, I have to give some credit to their wardrobe design and the thought and creativity that went into it. 
We will look into the most iconic dresses of Padme Amidala and do a breakdown of the influences behind them. Each post will be dedicated to one of these dresses.
The first one of these series is the one I like to call the “Red Invasion” gown. It’s featured the first time we see Natalie Portman’s character in The Phantom Menace, and it’s probably one of the most iconic gowns she has.

This gown is made of embroidered silk and faux fur that lines the double collar, tabards, double sleeves and hem. The alien-like touch is given to the dress by the electric lights placed on the skirt, that are made to resemble ladybugs.
The head piece that accompanies this dress is also pretty iconic in and on it…

A look into Star Wars: Padme's dresses. Part X

The last design from Episode II which we are going to be covering is the wedding gown, which happens to be the literal last outfit worn by the character in the movie.

She wears this dress in the final scene of Episode II, during her wedding with Anakin. It's a brief scene, but somehow people really remember this gown.
The design consists of an intricate gown made of lace and beads that goes with a lace veil. The gown is long and flowing, and has a small tail. The white fabric is decorated with an off-white delicate embroidery. The sleeves reach her elbows and are hemmed with scalloped lace. The entire gown is studded with pearls.

This gown takes from various historical sources, most of them pertaining to the early 20th century. The basic one with which it work are Edwardian fashion (1901-1911) and the 1920's.
The basic structure, with the gown and the laced overdress, is clearly taken from late Edwardian fashion.

These dresses (dated 1912) are quite similar to Padme's gow…